Nicholson House Inn and Spa

My husband and I had a lovely stay at the Nicholson House. Despite the absence of an in-person reception desk, there was absolutely no issue with check-in or check-out~it was super easy. Our room was a Deluxe Queen (#5) and it was very nicely appointed. When we checked in there were Madelines as well as a decanter with bourbon, freshly ground coffee with a French press, an electric kettle and an assortment of teas. There was a carafe with filtered water as well as milk in the fridge. No plastic cups or glasses here; instead, nice drinking glasses and coffee cups. Two comfortable robes as well as very nice bath amenities were waiting for us in a beautiful tiled bathroom. And what a nice perk to have heated floors in the bathroom! The bed was very comfortable with nice linens and there were nice plush towels in the bathroom. No scratchy sheets or skimpy towels here! There were coupons for breakfast which you could get at The Waiting Room, a few doors down. The selections for breakfast as well as coffee drinks were varied and very nice. We had breakfast there two days and my husband went there one afternoon to enjoy a glass of wine. He said it was very nice for a little afternoon break. I’d say staying at the Nicholson House is like staying with a good friend who welcomes you to her home and has a beautiful guest room ready for you. We were fortunate to meet Mollie who showed us a Luxury Queen room as well as a Superior King suite. Both were roomier than our Deluxe Queen room and the Superior King was especially nice. When we next visit Mendocino, we will reserve a Luxury Queen room for a little extra space. I would not hesitate to return to the Nicholson House~it’s a lovely place, very comfortable with plenty of special touches to welcome you. Another perk is that you can walk to the shops and restaurants in town~location is ideal!

The Nicholson House property is located in the beautiful town of Mendocino and a convenient walk to all the town has to offer. While the property is charming and well-kept, I had several issues with my stay and ultimately wished I'd stayed elsewhere. Because there are no staff on-property, you have the option of messaging via their online portal, calling via phone, or going next door to the cafe to speak with a staff member. I attempted all three of those methods without much assistance. I arrived to the property just before check-in and sent a message via the portal. The next morning after still no response, I went over to the cafe to inquire. The barista let me know the manager was out of town, and they too were having a hard time getting in touch with her. I then attempted to call the property (a total of three times) each time going to voicemail. Eventually my call was returned, however, the service I received was not satisfactory. I spent the entire night awake listening to a very loud family below me and could even hear my neighbor snoring through the wall (with ear plugs in). I requested a white-noise machine or another solution - an air purifier was provided to drown out the sound of screaming children and parents. Ultimately, if you appreciate responsive staff and quiet, peaceful accommodations, I would strongly recommend choosing a different property.

We were disappointed with our recent stay at Nicholson House. The "no contact" check-in process was very impersonal. For a bed and breakfast, we would have appreciated a bit more personal attention, especially for the rates being chared. Aslo, the "continental breakfast" was not very good. it was served at the public cafe next door to the inn, and was below what we expeced for a B&B, especially one affiliated with a leading restaurant. Our room, #9, was a basement room, with a view fo a public walkway. We had to keep the shades drawn for privacy. We will not be making a return visit here.

The room was small but well appointed. The king size bed and pillows were exceptional. It's an excellent location for exploring the Mendocino coast. The bathroom floor is heated, and the shower is roomy with great water pressure. Other than the croaking frogs as you arrive, the location is noticeably quiet.

My partner and I and our dog Squash had the pleasure of staying in one of the newly launched pet-friendly garden rooms and we had the best time. The room was beautifully decorated and it had a great mix of period details (like the hinges and hardware) and modern amenities (heated bathroom floors). The grounds were stunning and the building is centrally located. The Waiting Room (breakfast and coffee), The Brickery (pizza garden) and Beaujolais (dinner) are all located next to the rooms and offer such great eating options. Don’t skip the smash burger at The Brickery on Wednesdays and Thursdays. We stayed with our dog and were welcomed with a doggy blanket, towel, treats and even doggy bowls. We felt welcomed, immediately upon arrival. Bother the Waiting Room and The Brickery are super dog friendly. And the hotel is also walking distance to the beach and all the dog-friendly shops in town. The check-in and check-out experience were all virtual and super easy, but not impersonal. We really can’t wait to come back. Our entire family had the best time in Mendocino and at Nicholson House.

This place is amazing! Service, details, decor, and little surprise touches make this the most charming and comfortable place! The staff is amazing, the housekeeping staff outstanding, (cleanest hotel I have ever seen) and the entire place is just magical. I’ve been in the hospitality business for 20 plus years, and the Nicholson House knows what they are doing!